Political Chowder's NUMBER OF THE WEEK - Sponsored by www.no-deal.org Spooky Business
|
www.no-deal.org CONCORD – FairPoint Communications Inc. will be too deep in debt if it is allowed to borrow $1.7 billion to acquire the land line operations of Verizon Communications in New Hampshire, Maine and Vermont, consultant John Antonuk testified yesterday. Antonuk, founder and president of Liberty Consulting Group in Quentin, Pa., filed testimony on behalf of the staff of the New Hampshire Public Utilities Commission. Antonuk, under questioning by state Consumer Advocate Meredith Hatfield, said FairPoint's leverage ratio -- a number figured by dividing its debt by its earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA) -- would be 5.75 in the first year and 5.5 thereafter, which he said was "relatively high." Leverage ratios for similar deals "is 4.75 in the first year and 4.5 in the years thereafter," Antonuk said. Yesterday was the fourth day of an evidentiary hearing that will help the PUC decide whether to approve FairPoint's pending $2.715 billion acquisition of Verizon Communications wireline business in the three northern New England states. If it receives all needed regulatory approvals, FairPoint hopes to close on the deal in January 2008. Antonuk said he is not opposed to the deal if the PUC imposes conditions that lessen the risk to New Hampshire customers. Purchase of the northern New England assets is being funded by FairPoint at the parent level with about 37 percent equity and 63 percent debt according to testimony filed by Michael J. Balhoff, managing partner of Balhoff & Rowe, LLC, in Columbia, Md., and a financial expert retained by FairPoint to assess its financial strength. When it announced the deal in January, Charlotte, N.C.-based FairPoint Communications said for the year ended Dec. 31, 2005, the operations of Verizon's Maine, New Hampshire and Vermont properties to be merged with FairPoint generated approximately $1.2 billion in revenue and $431 million in EBITDA. Another witness, David Brevitz, yesterday also questioned the debt load FairPoint wants to carry under the proposed deal. Brevitz, an independent telecommunications consultant with Brevitz Consulting Services, in Topeka, Kansas, was hired by the Office of Consumer Advocate. "The call for this commission is whether this transaction makes sense from a Main Street perspective, and my testimony is that it does not," Brevitz said, citing the proposed debt arrangement. Under questioning from attorney Patrick McHugh, of the Devine, Millimet law firm, which is representing FairPoint, Brevitz also questioned a report filed by Verizon with the PUC that showed Verizon was losing $18 million a year on its New Hampshire land line operations as of Dec. 31, 2006. "It does show that and if that were really the case, you wonder why FairPoint is spending $2.7 billion to acquire an operation like that," Brevitz said. "I just don't believe that that's really the underlying economics for the enterprise."
|